This is my current favorite cinnamon roll recipe, adapted from "Jailhouse potato-cinnamon rolls" in Pastry Queen by Rebecca Rather. I've added an overnight rise inspired by Alton Brown, cut the recipe in half so it fits in a mixer, and found I need more flour (and more baking time) than Rather claims. The recipe still feeds an army (16 good-sized rolls), but it can be doubled with big enough bowls. (Use 3 whole eggs instead of 2 eggs and 2 yolks.)
Start by peeling, cubing, and boiling one medium russet potato for ~15 minutes in unsalted water. Save the water and let it cool to ~110 F (or add a little ice to speed it on its way). Mash 8 oz of potato in the stand mixer using the beater or whisk. Now, you can combine the other ingredients directly in the mixer using the whisk:
- 8 oz (1 c) mashed russet potato
- 1.5 c potato water, cooled to <110 f="" li="">
110>
- 4 t (0.5 oz) rapid-rise or bread-machine yeast
- 2 5/8 oz (3/8 c) sugar
- 1 stick (1/2 c) butter, melted
- 1 egg plus 1 yolk
- 1 t salt
Whisk well to combine, then use the dough hook to mix in flour just until the dough comes together:
- 30 oz (~6 c) unbleached all-purpose flour
Let dough rise, covered, until doubled, about 1 hour. (It will fill the mixer bowl to the top.)
For the filling, use either
- 2 c brown sugar
- 1 T cinnamon
- 2 c toasted pecans (optional)
or
- 2 c granulated sugar
- 1 T orange zest (from one orange)
Divide the dough in half, and roll each half out into a large rectangle. Brush each half with
- 2-3 T melted butter
Top each dough half with half the filling, roll it up, and slice into 8 rolls (16 total). We typically arrange these as a Christmas tree shape on a half sheet pan (rows of 1, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1). You could also put them in a 9x13 pan (5 rows of 3, cut one less roll) or two smaller pans. Refrigerate overnight; rolls will rise slowly. Alternately, freeze rolls and wrap well; thaw overnight in the refrigerator.
Remove rolls from refrigerator and preheat oven to 375 F. (Set rolls over a pan of hot water if they need to rise more, although they will expand significantly in the oven.) Bake rolls until dough is set in the centermost rolls, about 35-40 minutes in the Christmas tree configuration. I think the dough in the middle needs to reach 175-180 F or so to set -- in the Christmas tree configuration, the rolls on the edges are deeply browned by this point. Next time I might try a somewhat lower temperature for a longer time, or tenting the top with foil. Baking time in a high-sided pan is likely to be quite different, but might result in more uniform rolls.
Cinnamon rolls should be frosted with
- 4 3/4 oz (1 1/4 c) powdered sugar
- 2 T buttermilk (or milk)
- 1/4 t vanilla extract
Orange rolls should be frosted with
- 4 3/4 oz (1 1/4 c) powdered sugar
- 2 T fresh-squeezed orange juice (from one orange)
- 1 T orange zest (from one orange)
I've tried using orange extract to amp up the orange flavor of these rolls, but the alcohol gave it an unpleasant taste. I'm considering a mixed citrus version (lime? grapefruit?) next year.